Edward Said vedio

Edward Said is from an Arabic descent living in America or to generalize -the west-, his way of looking at things is similar to a lot of people in the middle east. Said was simply stating what actions he saw out of the American public and what has been said about middle easterners, and for that was portrayed as an anti-Americanism? then it means that if you are not with us in every step of the way then you must be against us, what an absurd concept.

Orientalism began way back in history, made for the purpose to form a detailed idea about a certain nation, their habits and norms and how would they deal with different kinds of situations, for orientalists to return with a full inside look back to their country that wanted to concur that nation. We can see a similar process happening again in our time and age, but this time is different, where its purpose is aimed to figure out how we may take the most advantage of their natural resources, which means that acquiring knowledge is highly motivated. Or did you think that all the studies about the middle east is to express the admiration of other cultures, or for the love of exploring other civilizations that colors this beautiful world? really?

Hollywood’s portrait of Arabs is always wrong, that for the big part of it is really racist, not talking about Aladdin by the way, whatever Hollywood brings to the screen it will always be offensive, not because I’am already predisposed to thinking so but because its truly inappropriate. Hollywood will always be Hollywood, where blame can lead us to nowhere and no ears would ever listen. On the other hand, the news was suspicious of everyone who looked Arabic and have generalized the description to the middle-eastern public, unfortunately the American public has followed, forming certain images in their mind when they see an Arab or hear about one. In addition, the news is following statements and actions of the government, for example, you do not see reports on U.S. networks that shows the horribles of Palestinian massacres on the hands of Israelis soldiers, more and more day after day living the nightmares of their homes being destructed and losing sense of their Palestinian identities as well as their dear land, but on the contrary, you see the groups who are trying to defend their land are the ones who are called terrorists, all because the U.S. government have a certain affiliation with the Israeli government.

What Said has brought up regarding how Arabs are generalized with a certain adjective, is just a small dot in a sea, there are many areas in life that could be touched on and explained more to clarify the time being situation, the past and what could be a solution in the future 

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Edward Said vedio

  1. cvolpe706 says:

    I see you’re referencing/responding to my blog post… In my opinion Said’s interview does more than “simply state what actions he saw out of the American public and what has been said about middle easterners” – it makes huge generalizations of Americans, American media, and American society. My main point is that when Said’s book was published, in the late 70s, there no exposure to American Media in the Middle East so readers were impacted significantly more than they would be today. I don’t see, at all, how that means “if you are not with us in every step of the way then you must be against us” and I absolutely don’t believe my opinion is “absurd”.

    You state “Whatever Hollywood brings to the screen it will always be offensive” but say its not because you’re already predisposed to thinking so… This argument is not logical… If you already have a preconceived notion of what Hollywood will bring in the future before even having seen it, you exemplify a predisposition.

    “We’re not talking about Aladdin by the way”? Aladdin, by the way, is one of the clips referenced in Said’s video and an example we talked about in class – which I why I discussed it in my post.

    Glad to be inspiration for your first blog post!

    p.s. It’s VIDEO not VEDIO! 🙂

    • hamzabu50 says:

      I certainly did not mean that your opinion is absurd, what I simply meant was that if you were following that concept “if you are not with us in every step of the way then you must be against us” then and only then it would be an absurd position. And I totally agree that generalizations are extremely wrong, but what I think Said meant that the majority of the American society are making hasty conclusions about any event that happened putting the blame on a certain ethnic group as history have shown us. I was poking at Hollywood because of the fact that they always show an Arabic as ignorant and for the purpose to be made fun of, moreover, distorting parts of history when bringing a historical event into a movie, ex. The Da Vinci Code, and maybe its just me but it has been a while since I have seen a GREAT movie being produced any more, just a cycle of silly movies! only a few that really stands out.

      p.s. Thank you for clarifying that typo. 🙂

  2. cvolpe706 says:

    I see you’re referencing/responding to my blog post…

    In my opinion Said’s interview does more than “simply state what actions he saw out of the American public and what has been said about middle easterners” – it makes huge generalizations of Americans, American media, and American society. My main point is that when Said’s book was published, in the late 70s, there was no exposure to American Media in the Middle East. So, readers were impacted significantly more than they would be today. I don’t see, at all, how that means “if you are not with us in every step of the way then you must be against us” and I absolutely don’t believe my opinion is “absurd”.

    You state “Whatever Hollywood brings to the screen it will always be offensive” but say its not because you’re already predisposed to thinking so… This argument is not logical… If you already have a preconceived notion of what Hollywood will bring in the future before even having seen it, you exemplify a predisposition.

    “We’re not talking about Aladdin by the way”? Aladdin, by the way, is one of the clips referenced in Said’s video and an example we talked about in class – which I why I discussed it in my post.

    Glad to be inspiration for your first blog post!

    p.s. It’s VIDEO not VEDIO! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s